How to Address Performance Issues with Empathy: Manager's Guide
You have been avoiding it. The missed deadlines, the dropped balls, the conversations you have had in your head a dozen times. Now you have to actually say it out loud — and you need to do it in a way that preserves their dignity while being clear about what needs to change.
The reply
Subject: Check-in Dear [Employee's Name], I would like to schedule some time to talk about how things are going. I have noticed a few areas where I think we can work together to get you back on track, and I want to make sure we address them early. This is not a disciplinary conversation — it is a support conversation. My goal is to understand what is getting in the way and figure out how I can help. Are you available for [30 minutes] on [day]? [Your Name] --- During the conversation: "I want to talk about something that has been on my mind. I have noticed [specific behavior or output] over the past [timeframe]. For example, [specific instance]. I am bringing this up because I believe in your potential here, and I want to make sure you have what you need to succeed. Can you help me understand what might be contributing to this? Is there something I can do to support you better?" [Listen. Then:] "Here is what I would like to see change: [specific expectation]. Let us set a timeline of [timeframe] and check in [frequency]. Does that feel reasonable?"
Why this works
- It frames the conversation as support because when someone hears they are underperforming, their first instinct is defensiveness — 'I want to help' disarms that before it starts.
- It uses specific examples because 'you need to do better' is cruel in its vagueness; naming exactly what you observed makes the problem solvable.
- It asks for their perspective because nobody wants to be talked at — inviting them into the conversation turns it from a verdict into a collaboration.
- It ends with a clear agreement because ambiguity creates anxiety; knowing exactly what is expected and when you will check in gives them a path forward.
Different tones
If the issue is serious
"I need to be direct with you. [Specific behavior] has fallen below the standard we need, and it is affecting [specific impact]. I want to be clear: this is serious, but it is also fixable. I am committed to helping you turn this around. Here is what needs to change: [specific expectation]. We will check in [frequency] to review progress. If we do not see improvement by [date], we will need to discuss next steps. I believe you can do this. Let us figure out how."
Common mistakes to avoid
- 1.Waiting too long — address issues early before they become patterns.
- 2.Being vague — 'you need to do better' is not actionable.
- 3.Making it personal — focus on behavior, not character.
- 4.Not documenting — write a brief summary after the conversation for both of you.
Frequently asked questions
Should I give them a warning?
Frame it as a clear expectation with consequences, not a threat. 'If X does not improve by Y, we will need to discuss Z.'
What if they get defensive?
Stay calm. Acknowledge their feelings: 'I can see this is hard to hear.' Then return to specifics.
How do I follow up without micromanaging?
Set specific check-in dates in advance. Ask them to come prepared with updates on their progress.
Share this
This is not a disciplinary conversation — it is a support conversation.
The Performance Conversation Nobody Wants to Have
KindReply
Related Workplace Situations
More templates for navigating work with confidence
Feedback That Actually Lands
When you have hard feedback and you are tired of watching it bounce off.
The Apology That Rebuilds What You Broke
When you have let someone down and you need to earn back their trust.
When They Ask for More and You Have Nothing Left to Give
Your employer expects unpaid overtime and you need to decline without jeopardizing your job or reputation.
Loved this reply?
Get new workplace templates delivered to your inbox. One email per week, no spam.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime. We respect your inbox.